There are NO Bad Patent Examiners

Book summary

There are NO Bad Patent Examiners: The unofficial guide to working with the “good” ones by Mary Maille (Molly) Lyons is an insightful, practical and often humorous guide to understanding how patent examination works from the perspective of someone who has spent years on the other side of the application.

Drawing on more than a decade of experience examining biotechnology patents at the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO), Lyons takes readers behind the scenes of a process that inventors and patent professionals often find complex, frustrating and difficult to navigate.

The book's deliberately provocative title captures its central premise: patent examiners are not necessarily the adversaries that applicants sometimes perceive them to be. Most are dedicated professionals performing a demanding public service, although their experience, approaches and communication styles inevitably differ.

The book covers the fundamentals of intellectual property, patentability requirements, patent claims, prior art searches, office actions, objections, rejections, prosecution strategies and examiner interviews. It also provides practical insights into how patent attorneys and inventors can communicate more effectively with examiners, avoid unnecessary complications and improve the efficiency of the examination process.

Particularly interesting are the chapters explaining how examiners interpret patent claims, evaluate arguments and respond to different prosecution strategies. Lyons draws on real experiences to illustrate what can make an argument persuasive, why certain approaches are less effective and how misunderstandings can unnecessarily prolong patent prosecution.

What makes this book distinctive is its combination of technical knowledge, personal experience and humour. Lyons uses analogies involving fences, tennis matches and everyday situations to make complex patent examination concepts more accessible. Her personal stories, occasionally self-deprecating observations and reflections on the USPTO's internal working environment give the book an unusually human character.

The underlying message is simple: successful patent prosecution is not only about understanding patent law. It is also about clear communication, professional respect and keeping the inventive concept at the centre of the process.

What you’ll learn

• How patent examiners actually work: Understanding their responsibilities, examination processes, internal procedures and the practical realities of working at the USPTO.
• How patent applications are assessed: An accessible explanation of patent eligibility, novelty, non-obviousness, written description, enablement and other examination requirements.
• Why patent claims matter: How claim language defines the scope of protection and why apparently small wording differences can significantly influence examination outcomes.
• How to navigate patent prosecution: Understanding office actions, objections, rejections, amendments, examiner interviews, continued examination and appeals.
• What makes arguments persuasive: Insights from an examiner's perspective into effective and less-effective approaches to responding to patent rejections.
• How to avoid unnecessary examination complications: Common drafting, formatting and communication issues that can generate avoidable objections or rejections.
• How the USPTO's working environment influences examination: Insights into examiner training, supervision, performance expectations and administrative procedures.
  

Who is this book best for

Patent attorneys and patent agents

Particularly valuable for practitioners involved in US patent prosecution who want to better understand how examiners approach applications, interpret claims, assess arguments and make examination decisions.

Independent inventors and entrepreneurs

A useful introduction for inventors seeking to understand what happens after filing a patent application, why applications receive rejections and how to work more effectively with their patent representatives.

IP offices and patent examiners

An interesting insider perspective on patent examination practice, examiner training, professional judgement and the importance of constructive engagement with applicants.

IP consultants and innovation advisors

Useful for professionals who help inventors, start-ups and research organisations understand patent processes and make informed decisions about protecting inventions.

Students and early-career IP professionals

An accessible introduction to the realities of patent examination that complements more formal academic and legal resources.

Why we selected this book

At weareip, we selected There are NO Bad Patent Examiners because it offers something that is not always found in conventional intellectual property publications: a candid, first-hand perspective on the people and processes behind patent examination.

Much of the literature on patents concentrates on legal requirements, drafting techniques, prosecution procedures and judicial decisions.

This book addresses an equally important dimension: what happens when a patent application reaches the examiner's desk, and how can inventors and patent professionals navigate that relationship more effectively?

One of its strongest contributions is the way Lyons challenges the perception of patent examination as an inherently adversarial process.

Examiners have a responsibility to assess whether an invention deserves patent protection and to establish an appropriate scope of exclusive rights. Patent attorneys, meanwhile, represent the interests of inventors seeking protection for their innovations.

These responsibilities are different, but they need not create an unnecessarily confrontational relationship.

Lyons makes a convincing case for understanding the examiner's perspective, communicating clearly and concentrating on the substance of the invention rather than treating prosecution as a contest between opposing sides.

Another distinctive feature is the author's willingness to reflect critically on her own experience. She discusses mistakes made earlier in her examining career, the lessons learned through training and mentorship, and how her approach evolved over time.

This gives the book credibility beyond its technical explanations. It reminds readers that patent examination involves professional judgement, continuous learning and human interaction, not merely the mechanical application of legal rules.

We also particularly appreciate the author's use of humour.

From the deliberately exaggerated title to the repeated reminders that the book is unofficial, unsanctioned, unendorsed, unsponsored and absolutely not legal advice, Lyons brings a refreshingly informal voice to a highly technical subject.

Behind the humour, however, lies a serious message: better understanding between inventors, patent professionals and examiners can contribute to a more effective patent examination process.

For us, that makes this book more than an entertaining introduction to patent prosecution. It is also a valuable contribution to how intellectual property knowledge can be communicated in a clearer, more accessible and more human way.

Editorial note

This book focuses primarily on the United States patent system and reflects the author's personal experience as a former USPTO patent examiner, particularly in biotechnology.

It is an independent publication and is not an official USPTO guide or an authoritative statement of USPTO policy.

Some of the author's observations, interpretations and suggested approaches reflect personal professional experience rather than universally applicable examination practices. Patent laws, examination procedures and administrative policies may also change over time.

The book should therefore be read as an educational and practical insider perspective, rather than a substitute for professional legal advice or official examination guidance.

Affiliate disclosure

Some links on this page may be affiliate links. If you buy a book through these links, weareip may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.